This article dives into the complex legal and ethical challenges faced by the Puerto Rico Bar Association (PRBA), known as the Colegio de Abogados y Abogadas de Puerto Rico (CAAPR). As the oldest professional association in Puerto Rico, the CAAPR has played a pivotal role in the legal landscape of the territory. However, recent legal conflicts have cast a shadow over its operations and ethical standing. A significant legal challenge in 2011, involving a court order for the CAAPR to pay a substantial sum and prohibiting the use of member dues for ideological purposes, marked a turning point in the association's fiduciary responsibilities. Subsequent litigation against its insurance provider raised questions about the CAAPR's compliance with legal and ethical standards. The impact of these legal disputes extends beyond institutional concerns, directly affecting individual members, particularly those exempt from dues due to disability. The denial of life insurance benefits to these members, despite contractual assurances, highlights a breach of trust and a disregard for the rights of the association's most vulnerable members. This situation not only reveals a lack of integrity within the CAAPR but also underscores the systemic issues within the legal community of Puerto Rico. The article further explores the legal implications of these actions under Puerto Rican law and the U.S. legal framework, particularly focusing on the rights and obligations stipulated in 42 U.S. Code § 1983—Civil action for deprivation of rights. The CAAPR's failure to fulfill its legal and moral obligations to its members suggests a serious breach of legal and ethical standards. This analysis serves as a call to action for accountability and justice, urging the CAAPR to rectify its errors and uphold its duties to its members. The article concludes by emphasizing the broader implications of this case and the need for systemic reform within the legal fraternity of Puerto Rico.
See Full PDF See Full PDF[CON]TEXTS: PARQUE MUÑOZ RIVERA AND THE SUPREME COURT OF PUERTO RICO
[CON]TEXTS: PARQUE MUÑOZ RIVERA AND THE SUPREME COURT OF PUERTO RICO by Andrés Mignucci translated by Andrew Hurley. Published by La Rama Judicial de Puerto Rico, 2012 ISBN: 978-0-9885412-1-4
Download Free PDF View PDF
